Do You Really Need Dog Training Treats, or Will Their Normal Food Do?
Ask two dogs to sit, then offer each a piece of their usual kibble. One looks delighted. The other gives it a sniff and looks at you as if to say, ‘Is that the best you’ve got?’
Some dogs will happily work for their dinner, especially for easy training at home. Others want something more exciting from the very first lesson. And even a dog that loves kibble in the kitchen might find it rather less interesting when a squirrel appears in the park.
That’s where dedicated training treats earn their place. A small, tasty, crunchy reward can be much more motivating than ordinary food, whether you’re teaching ‘sit’ in the kitchen or practising recall outside. It is why we make Bounce & Bella training treats: an appealing reward for your dog, with ingredients you can clearly identify. The trick isn’t to use the fanciest treat for everything. It’s to find something your dog genuinely wants to work for. [1][2]
Not every dog will work for its dinner
If your dog happily practises ‘sit’, ‘wait’ or ‘look at me’ for their normal food, great. Use it. But if kibble barely interests them, there is no prize for insisting on it. Some dogs need a reward they see as more valuable, even in a quiet room. Training treats can provide that extra incentive while you teach and reward the behaviour you want. [1][2]
If kibble works for your dog, it has a practical advantage. Set some aside from their measured daily food allowance before you fill the bowl, and those training rewards needn’t add extra calories to the day. But a dedicated training treat is equally useful when you need a stronger incentive, something easy to give repeatedly, or a change from their everyday dinner. You still need to count the total amount eaten. [2]
You can use both. Ordinary food for the moments when it does the job; a more exciting training treat when your dog needs a better reason to pay attention. And those moments don’t only happen outdoors.
What happens when the reward has competition?
Outdoors, even a dog that happily works for kibble at home might be weighing it against smells in the grass, another dog or that squirrel. A reward that was exciting in the kitchen may no longer be enough.
Researchers tested a version of this question by teaching dogs to run down a 20-metre track for food. In one experiment, dogs ran significantly faster for a preferred piece of sausage than for dry food. In another, offering five pieces of dry food instead of one did not produce the same improvement in running speed. [3]
That was a controlled runway experiment, not a test of recall in a busy park. It certainly does not prove that any particular brand of training treat will beat a squirrel. But it shows something useful: to a dog, the kind of reward can matter more than simply getting a bigger pile of it.
‘High value’ is decided by the dog, not the packet
Trainers often talk about high-value and low-value rewards. It sounds technical, but it just means your dog wants some rewards more than others. Kibble may do the job for an easy exercise. A tasty, crunchy reward, a tiny piece of cooked chicken or an exciting game might make a harder task worth the effort. That extra enthusiasm is precisely why dedicated training treats can be useful. [1][4]
There is no universal ‘best’ treat, and expensive does not automatically mean exciting. Some dogs love crunchy biscuits. Others would walk past them for a softer, smellier morsel. Some would rather chase a toy. What counts is what your dog actually works for, in that situation. [4]
That is what we aim for with Bounce & Bella Poultry Training Treats. They are small enough to reward quickly, have a satisfying crunch and contain 80% freshly prepared poultry, with all five ingredients named. We call it a high-value crunch because we want each little reward to feel worth earning. Crunch is part of their appeal; the real test is how enthusiastically your own dog responds. [7]
When a better treat is not the answer
Now imagine the squirrel is practically under your dog’s nose. They ignore the treat you normally save for special occasions. Do you need something even tastier?
Possibly not. You may simply be asking too much, too soon. Battersea’s training guidance explains that a dog can become so distracted or overwhelmed that they stop taking food or responding. The sensible response is to create more distance, reduce the distraction and practise where your dog can succeed. Gradually work towards harder situations. [5]
Food is a reward, not a way to push a frightened dog closer to something that scares them. And no treat is a substitute for patiently teaching recall or other important behaviours in manageable stages.
The calorie catch that is easy to miss
Good training can involve lots of little successes, especially when a dog is learning something new. Small treats let you reward those moments without interrupting the lesson. You still need to keep an eye on the calories, because small does not mean calorie-free.
Veterinary guidance recommends keeping treats and other extras to no more than about 10% of a dog’s daily calories, so most nutrition still comes from a complete and balanced diet. The limit is about calories, not the number or weight of treats. [6]
Our Poultry Training Treats are approximately 2.4 calories per piece, according to our published product information. That makes 20 rewards about 48 calories. For a dog whose established daily food target is 1,000 calories, that is just under half a 100-calorie daily extras allowance; for a dog with a 500-calorie target, it is almost the whole 50-calorie allowance. Those are illustrations, not feeding recommendations. The useful number depends on your dog, not the number of treats in someone else’s pocket. [6][7]
Not every day is a heavy training day. It is perfectly sensible to use more rewards on days when you are practising a lot and fewer when you are doing less. The trick is planning for that busy day rather than adding every treat on top of the usual meals: use some of the measured daily ration for easier repetitions, and save the exciting treats for the moments when they do more work. Adjust the main meal when appropriate so the daily calorie total stays sensible. The usual veterinary guidance is still that treats and other extras should stay within about 10% of daily calories; it is not a weekly allowance you can borrow against. If your dog needs a special diet, or your training regularly needs far more extras than that, ask your vet for a suitable feeding plan. [2][6]
So what should you put in your pocket?
Start with a little of your dog’s normal food. Try a short session somewhere quiet. If they are keen to work for it, excellent. You have your answer.
As you move to the garden, then to quieter places outdoors, watch whether the reward still matters to them. A dedicated training treat comes into its own when you need something convenient, quick to give and more exciting than the usual dinner. Use a reward your dog is keen to earn, or try play if that motivates them more. If they are too distracted to engage at all, make the training easier before reaching for an even fancier treat. [1][4][5]
We make Bounce & Bella training treats for the moments when an ordinary piece of kibble is not quite enough: teaching new skills, keeping a training session flowing and rewarding a dog for choosing you over the interesting world around them. Small pieces, a proper crunch and clearly named ingredients are deliberate features, not decoration. There is a place for ordinary food, and a place for something your dog gets excited about.
Our standard is simple: give your dog something worth working for, know what is in it and make room for it in the day's food. The best training treat is one that helps the lesson stick without leaving you guessing what you have fed.
Useful next reads
- How to Choose Dog Training Treats
- Treat Calories and the 10% Rule
- Dog Treat Labels Decoded
- Bounce & Bella Poultry Training Treats
Sources and footnotes
- Dogs Trust, ‘Positive reinforcement – training with rewards’. Supports reward-based training, using rewards the dog wants, different reward values in different environments, and reducing meal food when rewarding. https://www.dogstrust.org.uk/dog-advice/training/techniques/positive-reinforcement-training-with-rewards
- VCA Animal Hospitals, Canadian Academy of Veterinary Nutrition / Hunt & Wilson, ‘Using Food and Treats for Training Dogs’ (2026). Explicitly supports using normal kibble, keeping total calories in check, and individual reward preference. https://vcahospitals.com/know-your-pet/using-food-and-treats-for-training-dogs
- Riemer, Ellis, Thompson & Burman (2018), ‘Reinforcer effectiveness in dogs: The influence of quantity and quality’, Applied Animal Behaviour Science 206, 87–93. Tested speed on a 20 m runway, with sausage versus dry food in one study and one versus five dry-food pieces in another. Supports a task-specific effect of reward quality, not guaranteed success in real-world recall or for any B&B product. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applanim.2018.05.016
- Battersea Dogs & Cats Home, ‘Training motivations’, updated 3 July 2026. Food, toys and praise can motivate differently; individual dogs vary; high-value rewards can help with harder training. https://www.battersea.org.uk/pet-advice/dog-advice/training-motivations
- Battersea Dogs & Cats Home, ‘How to get your dog’s attention around distractions’, updated 30 June 2026. Explains threshold distance, signs of being over threshold, and increasing distractions gradually. https://www.battersea.org.uk/pet-advice/dog-advice/getting-dogs-attention
- World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA), ‘Feeding treats to your dog’ (November 2025 update). Advises that treats should be less than 10% of daily calories and must not replace a complete and balanced diet; veterinary advice is appropriate for individual needs. https://wsava.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/WSAVA_GuidetoTreats_Dogs_251107.pdf
- Bounce & Bella, Grain-Free Ultimate Training Treats for Dogs – Poultry. Current public product listing declares approximately 2.4 kcal per treat. That is a published product figure, not an independently verified laboratory measurement; the 20-piece illustration is arithmetic, not an individual feeding prescription. https://shop.bounceandbella.co.uk/products/grain-free-premium-poultry-treats-for-dogs
